How to Choose an Agency Mentor (and Questions to Ask Before You Pay)
The right agency mentor can save you years of expensive mistakes. The wrong one costs you money, time and confidence. Here's how to tell the difference before you sign anything.
Key Takeaways
- Choose someone who has built an agency to the level you want to reach, not just someone who coaches.
- Ask what they'll commit to in writing. Results beat access.
- Make sure you'll work with them directly, not a junior coach.
- Give it at least 6 months. Offer, lead generation and sales changes take time to show in revenue.
- If you can't afford a mentor yet, a peer one or two stages ahead of you is the next best thing.
Mentor, coach, course or mastermind?
These get used interchangeably, but they're different things. A course teaches you a system to implement on your own. A mastermind gives you a peer group and accountability. A coach mainly helps you find your own answers through questions. A mentor has already built what you're trying to build and tells you directly what works and what doesn't. If your problem is a knowledge gap and you're disciplined, a course may be enough. If you're stuck and don't know why, a mentor is usually the fastest fix. We compare all four in Agency Coach vs. Course vs. Mastermind.
7 questions to ask an agency mentor before you pay
1. Have you built an agency to the level I want to reach?
This matters more than anything else. Someone who has scaled their own agency past where you are has made the mistakes you're about to make. Ask for specifics: what kind of agency, what revenue, and over what time frame.
2. Will I work with you directly?
Many programs sell the founder's name, then hand you to a junior coach. That isn't necessarily bad, but you should know before you pay. Ask who you'll actually talk to, and how often.
3. What will you commit to in writing?
Access isn't a result. A mentor who believes in their process should be willing to commit to a specific outcome in your agreement. If all they'll promise is a number of calls, the risk sits entirely with you.
4. Can you show results from agency owners at my stage?
A mentor who helped someone go from $50K to $500K a month may not be the right fit if you're at $5K. Ask for named results from people who started where you are now. Vague claims like "helped hundreds of agencies" don't tell you much.
5. How long is the program, and why?
Changes to your offer, lead generation and sales process usually take 3 to 6 months to show up in revenue. Programs shorter than that often end just as results start. Programs much longer than that should be able to explain what you're paying for each month.
6. How will we figure out where I'm actually stuck?
Good mentorship starts with a proper diagnosis of your agency: your offer, pipeline, close rate, pricing and delivery. Generic advice for everyone is a course, not mentorship. You can get a head start with the free 5-Pillar Agency Scorecard.
7. How many people do you work with at once?
There's a limit to how many agency owners one person can genuinely help. A mentor with a capped number of mentees can give you real attention. One with hundreds can't.
Red flags to watch for
- Income screenshots instead of named client results.
- Pressure to decide on the first call, or "this price is only valid today."
- No clear answer on who you'll actually work with.
- A one-size-fits-all program that doesn't start with your numbers.
- Promises of results with no commitment in writing.
When is the right time to get a mentor?
Most agency owners get the most value from a mentor at one of three points: when they can't get past their first $5K to $10K a month, when they're stuck at $20K to $30K a month because everything runs through them, or when they're preparing to scale past $50K and need systems and a team. If you're not sure which stage you're at, the agency revenue calculator and our guides to $10K, $50K and $100K a month will help.
If you can't afford a mentor yet
Find a peer one or two stages ahead of you, not ten. Someone doing 2 to 3 times your revenue remembers your problems clearly, and many will happily take a call once a month. Bring one specific question each time. "Should we hire or raise prices first?" gets a much better answer than "can I pick your brain?" Agency communities and mentor marketplaces are also good places to find people willing to help.
The bottom line
The best agency mentor has already built what you're trying to build, works with you directly, starts with your actual numbers, and is willing to be held to a result in writing. If a mentor ticks those boxes, the investment usually pays for itself. If they don't, keep looking.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does an agency mentor do?
An agency mentor is someone who has already built a successful agency and helps you do the same. They diagnose where your agency is stuck, whether that's your offer, lead generation, sales process, closing or delivery, and tell you directly what to change, based on what worked for them.
Is an agency mentor better than an agency coach?
It depends on what you need. A coach mainly helps you find your own answers through questions and accountability. A mentor gives you direct answers from experience. If you're stuck and don't know why, a mentor who has already solved the same problem is usually faster.
How long should agency mentorship last?
At least six months. Changes to your offer, lead generation and sales process usually take 3 to 6 months to show up in revenue, so shorter programs often end just as results start.
Who is Terrence Kruse?
Terrence Kruse is the founder of Higher Level Agency and a ClickFunnels Two Comma Club winner. He built two agencies of his own to seven figures, has mentored 100+ agency founders, and works with a maximum of 30 mentees at a time. Read his story.
Looking for an agency mentor?
Work 1-on-1 with Terrence Kruse, a multi-7-figure agency owner, with 24/7 access. Under $5K/month, the target is $10K/month. Over $5K/month, it's double your revenue. Miss it in 6 months and Terrence keeps mentoring you free until you hit it.
Meet Your Agency Mentor